Cookies on this website
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you click 'Continue' we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies and you won't see this message again. Click 'Find out more' for information on how to change your cookie settings.

Results from a major clinical trial demonstrate that both stenting and surgery are low-risk and similarly effective procedures for treating carotid artery disease.

" "

The results, published today in The Lancetwere announced simultaneously at the European Society of Cardiology Congress 2021.

Stroke is the second largest cause of death worldwide, responsible for over six million deaths each year. A common cause of stroke is carotid artery disease (also known as carotid artery stenosis), where the large blood vessels that supply oxygen to the brain become narrower. Usually, this is due to deposits of fatty material (atherosclerosis) in the arteries which eventually form hardened plaques.

To reduce their risk of having a deadly stroke, patients with carotid artery disease may undergo one of two different procedures to open up the affected artery and improve blood flow to the brain. Carotid artery surgery, also called carotid endarterectomy (CEA), involves surgically removing the plaque, and is more commonly prescribed. Alternatively, the artery may be opened by inserting a catheter with an inflatable balloon tip, and then a stent added to permanently keep the walls open (carotid artery stenting, CAS).

Up to now it has been unclear which of these procedures results in better overall patient outcomes. This includes both the long-term protective effect against strokes, and the risk of an adverse event happening during or immediately after the operation.

To generate robust evidence that could answer this, researchers have coordinated the Asymptomatic Carotid Surgery Trial 2 (ACST-2), the largest trial to date comparing CAS and CEA. The trial, hosted by the Nuffield Department of Population Health at the University of Oxford, enrolled 3,625 participants from 33 countries. Each participant had been diagnosed with carotid artery disease that had not caused  a stroke.

After agreeing to take part in the study, participants were randomly allocated to undergo either CAS or CEA, and followed up for an average of five years. The main outcomes assessed by the trial were adverse events associated with the procedure itself, and the long-term protective effect against strokes.

Key results:

  • There was no significant difference in the risk of adverse, procedure-related events for CAS and CEA. For both treatments, 1% of patients had a disabling stroke or died within 30 days (15 in the CAS group and 18 in the CEA group) and 2% had a non-disabling stroke (48 in the CAS group and 29 in the CEA group).
  • The number of strokes that occurred in the participants over the five-year follow up period was similar for CAS and CEA. Fatal or disabling stroke occurred in 2.5% of patients in each group, and the total number of strokes was 5.3% in the CAS group, and 4.5% in the CEA group.

Principal Investigator for ACST-2 Professor Alison Halliday, Professor of Vascular Surgery in the Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences, University of Oxford, said: ‘We have shown that, for patients with a severely narrowed carotid artery, stenting and surgery have similar effects on the chances of having a disabling or fatal stroke. The risk from each procedure is about 1%. After that, however, the annual risk over the next five or more years is halved, from 1% down to 0.5% per year.’

Mr Richard Bulbulia, a Consultant Vascular Surgeon, Co-Principal Investigator for ACST-2, and Research Fellow at the Nuffield Department of Population Health, said: ‘Both stenting and surgery are good treatment options, but there may be particular patient factors which favour one approach over another. Until now, it had been unclear if CAS or CEA results in better overall outcomes on the risk of stroke. The evidence from this trial can give doctors confidence in offering the procedure most suited to their patients, knowing that both options are associated with similar very low risks.’

Similar stories

Dr Matthew Bottomley wins Stewart Cameron Science Award

Congratulations to Dr Matthew Bottomley, who has been announced as the joint winner of the Stewart Cameron Science Award by the Royal Society of Medicine (RSM).

Special issue of JNDS published

Journal of the Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences (JNDS) has published a new special issue, featuring highlights from the 2021 NDS Virtual Research Away Day.

Clare Verrill receives Turing Fellowship

Thirty-three University of Oxford researchers have been named Turing Fellows for the 2021/22 academic year, including Associate Professor Clare Verrill from the Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences (NDS).

Researchers awarded Wellcome Innovator Grant to investigate role of brainstem nucleus in human consciousness

Researchers at Oxford University have received a prestigious Wellcome Innovator Grant for investigating the role of the pedunculopontine nucleus (PPN) – a brainstem nucleus – in human consciousness.

Discovered gene patterns can predict prostate cancer treatment response

Nearly 40,000 men are diagnosed with prostate cancer each year in the UK. Perhaps the most significant clinical challenge today is deciding which type of treatment will work best for different patient groups.

New Associate Professors announced

The University of Oxford has announced the promotion to Associate Professor of two senior academics at the Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences.

Blog posts

Wrap up of 2021

After a brilliant year of hard work and dedication, the SITU team has done some reflection on 2021, focusing on key events, trial progression, and more. Read on to discover how the year 2021 went for the SITU team...

Celebrating Anti-Bullying Week with words of kindness

Keeva Heap, who is undertaking a communications work experience placement at the Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences (NDS), shares our words of kindness In honour of Anti-Bullying Week.

My virtual work experience with NDS and NDORMS

Louise Tan, a Year 12 student from Ballyclare in County Antrim, Northern Ireland, recently attended the joint NDS and NDORMS Virtual Work Experience. In this guest blog, Louise reflects on her experience.

Celebrating women of NDS

To celebrate 100 years since women were admitted as full members of the University and on the occasion of International Women's Day, a group of inspirational women in the Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences (NDS) reflect on their journeys, their place in Medical Sciences and their vision for the next 100 years.

The life of a research nurse: supporting the Oxford COVID-19 Vaccine Trial

Research nurses in the NHS are playing a crucial role in helping to trial new coronavirus treatments and vaccines. Three NDS research nurses stepped up to help with the fight against this new disease. Here Bhumika Patel shares her experience of working on the Oxford COVID-19 Vaccine Trial.